ROUTERA


Chapter 1- Power Sharing

Class 10th Social Science-Political Science (Civics) Points to Remember Chapter 1- Power Sharing


Power Sharing

Belgium

  • Geographical Position: Small country in Europe, bordered by the Netherlands, France, and Germany.
  • Area and Population: Smaller in area than Haryana, India. Population a little over one crore.
  • Ethnic Composition:
    • 59% live in Flemish region — speak Dutch
    • 40% live in Wallonia region — speak French
    • 1% speak German
  • Capital: Brussels - 80% speak French, 20% speak Dutch.
  • Important Point: In Brussels, Dutch-speaking people are a minority, unlike the rest of the country.
  • The minority French-speaking population was wealthier than the Dutch-speaking majority, leading to tension in the 1950s and 1960s, especially in Brussels.

Sri Lanka

  • Geographical Position: Small island in Asia, off the southern coast of Tamil Nadu.
  • Population: About two crore people, similar to Haryana's population.
  • Ethnic Composition:
    • 74% Sinhalese-speaking
    • 18% Tamil-speaking
    • 13% Sri Lankan Tamils (natives)
    • The rest are Tamil Lankans, descendants of plantation workers from India.
  • Religion:
    • Most Sinhalese are Buddhists.
    • Most Tamils are Hindus or Muslims. Christians constitute 7% of the population.
  • Majoritarianism in Sri Lanka: Belief that only the majority community should rule, disregarding minorities.
  • Examples of Majoritarianism:
    • Sinhalese made the official language by an Act in 1956, ignoring Tamil.
    • Preferential policies for Sinhalese in government jobs and education.
    • Promotion and protection of Buddhism.
  • Tamil people felt alienated due to these policies, leading to demands for equality and eventually, a civil war for Tamil Eelam, resulting in significant casualties and economic damage.

Accommodation in Belgium

  • Belgium amended its Constitution to accommodate every ethnic community, avoiding civil war or demands for autonomy.
  • The Belgian Method:
    • Equal number of Dutch and French-speaking ministers in the Central Government.
    • Special laws need majority support from each language group.
    • State Governments are independent of the central government.
    • Separate government for Brussels with equal representation for both linguistic groups.
    • A third government (Community Government) elected by Dutch, French, and German-speaking people, managing language, cultural, and educational issues.

Why is Power-Sharing Desirable?

  • Prudential Reasons:
    • Reduces the possibility of conflicts and political instability.
    • Prevents groups from overstepping their rights.
    • Ensures no single group subverts the constitution, fostering national unity.
    • Prevents oppression of minorities and negative impacts on the majority.
  • Moral Reasons:
    • Spirit of democracy requires power sharing.
    • Policies affecting people should involve their input.
    • Citizens’ participation is essential for democracy.
    • Moral reasons make power sharing valuable and essential.

Forms of Power Sharing

  • Between different organs of government: Legislature, Executive, Judiciary.
  • Among different levels of government: Central or Union government, State government.
  • Among different social groups: Religious and linguistic groups.
  • Through social movements forcing legal changes.
  • Pressure Groups influencing government policies: Farmers, workers, industrialists.
  • Political Parties ensuring competition and preventing concentration of power.